Power Book public sector pros on the best campaigns, worst reputations and their music of choice

March 15, 2017 by Ian Griggs

Hilary Clinton, Mike Ashley and Sir Phillip Green are among those who have managed their reputations the most poorly in the last 12 months, according to public sector entrants in PRWeek's Power Book.

News
Public sector comms pros, including Arun Arora, John Shields and Matt Brown, responded to the Power Book survey
Public sector comms pros, including Arun Arora, John Shields and Matt Brown, responded to the Power Book survey

Bad reputations

Simon Baugh, group director of comms at the Department for Transport, named Clinton as the person who had managed her reputation most poorly, while for Matt Brown, director of news at Transport for London, it was Ashley who won that dubious honour, adding that the Sports Direct boss had "provided an enduring image".


Amanda Coleman

But for Amanda Coleman (above), head of corporate comms at Greater Manchester Police, and Simon Enright, director of comms for NHS England, their bete noire for 2016 was Arcadia chairman Sir Phillip, following the collapse of BHS last year and his subsequent Select Committee appearance.


Asked to predict the biggest industry change in five years, Coleman said the acronym ‘PR’ would have been replaced with the phrase strategic communication.

Challenging times

Powerbook entrants were also asked what they thought the industry’s greatest challenge would be this year.
Brexit, naturally, loomed large for public sector comms experts, with Stephen Hardwick, director of corporate comms at HMRC, and Sam Lister, group director of comms for the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, among those who gave this answer.

Richard Caseby

Quizzed on what the greatest opportunity for the industry in 2017, Richard Caseby (above), director of comms for the Department of Work and Pensions, said he thought it was the ability to "produce great content without editorial filters".

Cream of the campaigns 

Respondents were asked to name their favourite campaign during the last year. 

John Shield, director of comms for the BBC, generously named C4’s campaign to promote the drama show ‘Humans’ as his favourite, while for Arun Arora, director of comms for the Church of England, it was Amazon’s ‘vicar and imam’ campaign.

John Shields

Regrets, they have had a few, but some respondents said "nothing" in answer to this question, although others, such as Enright, regretted "pudding" while Shield (above) named never learning the piano as his chief disappointment in life.

Desert island disc choices were as eclectic as the respondents themselves, with Paul Mylrea, director of comms for the University of Cambridge choosing ‘Don’t Give Up’ by Peter Gabriel while Claire Ainsley, director of comms for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, picked ‘Suedehead’, by Morrissey.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register
Already registered?
Sign in

Resources

Get our email newsletters