The 'Hacks vs Flacks' survey: Journalists covet PR pay packets, but high levels of job satisfaction for both

PRWeek's new survey of 300 respondents reveals what PRs really think of journalists, and vice versa. The latest excerpt highlights the respective pay packets and job satisfaction.

Flacks vs Hacks: One of these two professions is fairly satisfied with pay levels while the other is not
Flacks vs Hacks: One of these two professions is fairly satisfied with pay levels while the other is not
It may be true that one profession would struggle to survive without the other but, while many PRs and journalists work well together, sadly the relationship can be characterised by misunderstanding, mistrust or even anger on both sides.

PRWeek carried out a detailed investigation into hack-flack relations in the current media climate, surveying journalists and PRs over the course of a month to lift the lid on how both sides regard the relationship.

The areas we investigated included the basic competency of their professional counterparts, pay satisfaction, the capacity for drinking on the job and whether they could make a good fist of the other’s role.

Our online survey garnered 300 responses. Here are the main findings:

Money talks – journalists feel underpaid

If there is one reason why journalists regularly join the ‘dark side’, it is to work with happy people in funky offices and enjoy a better work/life balance. No? OK, the main reason is, of course, pay.

The survey found widespread dissatisfaction with pay among the journalists, with 58 per cent either disagreeing or strongly disagreeing with the statement "I am paid an appropriate amount of money for the job that I do", compared with nearly 70 per cent of PRs who agreed or strongly agreed with the same statement.

Only a third of journalists thought they were paid enough, while roughly the same proportion of PRs said they thought they should be paid more. But are journalists actively jealous of what their PR counterparts receive in their pay packets each month? Some 35 per cent admitted they were slightly green about what the other side earns while 31 per cent said they were not.

One journalist mounted their high horse to tell the survey: "It does seem unjust that those paid to keep the public in the dark earn more than those who fight for transparency and accountability." Another journalist was more sanguine, writing: "They are paid more but they don’t seem to have as much fun."

Strangely, no PRs told the survey that they were jealous of the pay levels in journalism, while a decisive 81 per cent said they were not remotely jealous of what journalists earn.

One PR wrote: "A major factor in my moving from journalism to PR was the pay and job security."

Another was kind enough to write "we all know journalists aren’t paid nearly as well as they should be" and a third, less kindly, said: "You’re having a laugh, aren’t you?" We rest our case.

PRs and journalists are pretty satisfied with their jobs

When Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn was asked for his thoughts on the European Union in the run-up to the June referendum, he famously – or infamously – gave it a lukewarm "seven, or seven and a half" out of 10.

We asked journalists and PRs to rate their job satisfaction on a similar scale (out of 10) and found many on both sides damning their professions with faint praise, in a manner worthy of Corbyn.

Only one per cent of journalists put their job satisfaction at ‘one’. An encouraging 52 per cent gave a ‘seven’ or ‘eight’ score for job satisfaction, while 23 per cent said ‘nine’ and 14 per cent gave their job top marks. PRs told a similar story on job satisfaction, with 52 per cent also giving their profession a ‘seven’ or an ‘eight’, while nearly a quarter said ‘nine’ and nine per cent said ‘10’.

PR is still a crucial information source, according to many journalists

The media landscape is in a state of continuing flux as it adjusts to the digital age and continues to produce quality journalism with ever-shrinking resources. And, of course, as the media adapt, so too does the relationship between journalists and PRs.

Asked whether they thought PRs were as crucial a source of information as they were five years ago, 32 per cent of the journalists surveyed either agreed or strongly agreed that they were, while 34 per disagreed or strongly disagreed with the statement.

Some journalists admitted, ruefully, that PRs were more important in the current media landscape. One said: "They are more crucial, regrettably, because newsrooms are far shorter on staff than they were five years ago."

But more traditional voices made it clear that, until the bitter end, they would fight a stiff rearguard action against the encroachment of PR into the media.

One told the survey: "PRs were never crucial information sources. No half-decent journalist uses PRs as a source or even speaks to a PR until they need a right of reply... The practice of restricting all media communication to a PR officer is appalling and should be strongly resisted."

PRs, meanwhile, made it clear that the influence of journalists on the success or failure of their work was waning.

While 44 per cent either agreed or strongly agreed that journalists were still crucial to achieve clients’ aims, 39 per cent either disagreed or strongly disagreed with this statement.

Many PRs commented on how the rise of social media and influencers had circumvented the need to get stories into traditional media outlets. However, they said journalists provided the crucial balance and impartiality too often missing from social-media outlets.

One PR told the survey: "Social-media influencers have become influential, to some extent, to drive a news story. However, journalists provide mindfully considered content to flesh out details of a story, which is vital to drive a thoughtful conversation."

However, another PR was damning of the influence of journalism, commenting: "The days of a journalist or editor being the gatekeeper as to whether a PR campaign/story is a success or not are over."

Read the final part of our 'Hacks vs Flacks' survey tomorrow to find out what PRs and journalists love and loathe about each other and which media outlets and PR agencies they admire most.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Already registered?
Sign in