The CIPR welcomed the "simplified structure" of the new regime, but the PRCA continued its previous opposition to the NLA, saying the new structure was "smoke and mirrors" and vowing to challenge it.
A heated exchange took place on Twitter that evening in the weekly #PRtalk discussion, with PRCA director general Francis Ingham saying it was "tragic" that the CIPR had been "used" by the NLA, and accusing the CIPR of engaging in "secret talks" with the NLA. CIPR PR and policy manager Andrew Ross rejected Ingham's suggestions that the CIPR was in league with the NLA, saying: "We were approached upon consultation which isn't uncommon; saying otherwise is misleading."
Both bodies said they were open to further debate on the industry's relationship with the NLA.
On 24 November, a PRCA-branded email from consultancy Question & Retain was sent to nearly 11,000 PR professionals – with a little under 9,000 of these being non-PRCA members, and the rest being PRCA members. The PRCA says the survey was designed to reach "the broadest possible sample of members of the PR industry". Of the 483 respondents:
- 69 per cent said: 'I favour the PRCA approach – legal challenge to change the licensing law'
- 21 per cent said: 'I favour the CIPR approach – negotiation to change the licence prices’
- 6 per cent said: ‘I have no opinion’
- 4 per cent said: 'None of the above' and wrote a more detailed response
A spokesman for the CIPR said engagement with the NLA was "both a common sense position and a sound public relations approach".
He said: "If the CIPR was to shut itself out of any kind of practical influence on this issue, it would not be acting in the best interests of members, particularly small businesses whose growth potential was restricted due to an unnecessarily complex licensing structure.
"Across the board, the CIPR wants to see the entire copyright position simplified and we will continue to approach achieving this objective proactively with all stakeholders."
Ingham, who writes about the NLA issue in his latest column for PRWeek, said: "I will tomorrow be writing to all of the other bodies representing PR professionals in the UK, inviting them to join a copyright council of war, and to co-ordinate our efforts. I would be utterly delighted if the CIPR were to join us in this effort."