Pearl Harbor scapegoats' case validated by movie

WASHINGTON: The families of two WWII commanders scapegoated for

Japan's ambush of Pearl Harbor 60 years ago are capitalizing on the

release of Disney's new film to help clear the names of their loved


Following the attack on December 7, 1941, a special commission appointed

by then-president Franklin D. Roosevelt found Lt. Gen. Walter Short and

Adm. Husband Kimmel responsible for the ambush, which killed 19,000


Both left the service several years later in disgrace, denied the

benefits and honor of full retirement at the highest rank served during

war time - a benefit enjoyed by all US servicemen at the time.

But as the movie Pearl Harbor shows, said Sam Waltz of PR firm Sam Waltz

Associates, Kimmel and Short were in fact "set up" by Washington to take

the fall for the attack. Waltz's agency has been pushing for vindication

on behalf of the men's families since 1998. "As the movie shows,

Washington had intercepted intelligence that was never relayed to the

men in Hawaii," noted Waltz, a former national head of the PRSA. "As a

result, they were not prepared."

Many historians believe that FDR allowed the attack on Pearl Harbor to

occur to stimulate domestic support for entering the war, Waltz


The ultimate goal of the families' endeavor is to have the president

posthumously promote both men to their wartime ranks and acknowledge

their innocence. Since 1998, Congress has twice passed resolutions

asking the president to do so, but so far the White House has not taken

up the issue.

The release of Pearl Harbor offers another chance, said Waltz. "This

movie is helping raise public literacy about the issue," he said. "We're

building on that by generating not only publicity and awareness but

requests to the White House by the media for their response - for them

to do the right thing."

Coverage of the issue last week included an 18-minute segment on MSNBC's

The News With Brian Williams, as well as a two-hour documentary on the

network. Both Inside Edition and ABC News had plans as of midweek to

tape segments in the home of the Kimmel family.

"Our goal all along has been to use the media as our advocates in

Congress and with the White House," said Waltz. "This movie has become

one more landmark event that we can build on to further our cause."

Scapegoats: A Defense of Kimmel and Short at Pearl Harbor, published by

the naval historian (USN Ret.) Capt. Edward 'Ned' Beach, also documents

the case of the commanders.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Already registered?
Sign in