BBC faces criticism for 'weak' response over insulting comments by Top Gear presenters

The BBC has been criticised for its response to complaints over insulting comments made by presenters of popular motoring show, Top Gear.

Insulting comments: Top Gear presenter Jeremy Clarkson
Insulting comments: Top Gear presenter Jeremy Clarkson

The corporation was forced to apologise to the Mexican ambassador last week over remarks on the motoring show branding Mexicans ‘lazy’, ‘feckless’ and ‘flatulent’, but also defended the show's presenters, saying national stereotyping was part of British humour.

But the programme was back in the news today again with suggestions of improper use of national stereotypes, this time directed at Albania.

Alan Twigg, managing partner at Seventy Seven PR, suggested the BBC’s response was ‘weak’.

‘In the light of the Gray and Keys situation, this is now getting to be an alarming area,’ he said.
 
‘Someone needs to be definitive and say this is acceptable and this isn’t and I think it’s got a bit woolly and therefore lots of people are terrified to say anything.
 
‘On the one hand it is humour, but I think you’ve got to be a bit sensitive and I think the BBC was a bit weak in how it responded to the cricism.’
 
Mark Stringer, founder of PrettyGreen, said: ‘The BBC is as always under exceptional scrutiny, and there is a fine line between what is humorous and what is offensive. However, we need to be careful that we're not moving towards a totally moderated media state where entertainers are banned from dancing around that fine line.
 
‘All media owners have to try to act responsibly without becoming bland and other media outlets love to amplify these situations. The question is always about tone and intent.’


In the latest episode of the popular motoring show, Clarkson and co were filmed in Albania to road-test cars for a mafia boss.

‘Apparently, what happens is Albanians go to England, get a job, buy a car and then bring it back with them,’ Clarkson said in one part of the show.

Writing in The Observer at the weekend, comedian Steve Coogan weighed in on the BBC, calling Top Gear's humour lazy and its presenters ‘three rich, middle-aged men laughing at poor Mexicans'.

‘The BBC's initial mealy-mouthed apology was pitiful. It cited the more benign rivalry that exists between European nations (ah, those arrogant French, over-organised Germans), and in doing so neatly sidestepped one hugely important fact – ethnicity,’ wrote Coogan.

‘The Beeb's hand-wringing suggested tolerance of casual racism, arguably the most sinister kind.’

Would you like to post a comment?

Please Sign in or register.

News by email...